Value barometer

In this exercise, participants deal with social values and enter into discussion about them.

Learning objectives

The participants…

• get a playful approach to questions about social values.
• reflect their own needs and values within society.
• practice “utopian thinking”.

Procedure

Background

We all have an idea of what is important to us for living together in a society shaped by our personal values and convictions that guide our actions. The participants engage in conversations exploring how a society might look if individual values were to become more central to society.

Preparation

The cards with the values and a brief explanation of each value are distributed around the room. In addition, 3-6 more blank DINA4 sheets & pens are distributed around the room. A glass is placed on each sheet. The glasses should all be the same shape and size. The question “What is important to us for a utopian society?” can be hung up in the room.

Implementation

1. Introduction (10-15 minutes)

After the facilitator has explained procedure and background of the method, the participants can walk around the room and look at the individual value cards. If participants still miss values that are important to them, they can write their own values on the blank papers with pens. If necessary, the facilitator can add more paper.

2. Weighing Values (5-10 minutes)

The facilitator poses the question: “What is important to us for a utopian society?” Each participant is given a handful of corn grains. Depending on which values they find important and how important, they distribute their corn grains among the corresponding glasses. As soon as a participant has distributed all the corn kernels, the person sits down again.

3. Looking at the results (5-10 minutes)

After all participants have distributed their corn kernels, everyone looks at the filled jars. The facilitator reads out all the values one after the other and holds up the corresponding jar for everyone to see. The glasses of varying fullness show that we, both individually and as a group, weigh individual values differently. How these values are weighted can vary from person to person, from group to group and from society to society. What the corresponding weighting means within the group can be reflected together in the evaluation.

4. Finding groups (5-10 minutes)

The evaluation takes place in small groups. To do this, each participant thinks about which value the person would like to continue working on and stands next to the value card. This should result in small groups of about four people. If necessary, the facilitator can divide a large group again to work on one value. It is not a problem if there is not a small group for each value.

5. Discussion in small groups (20-30 minutes)

The small groups find a place and discuss the following questions (download material):

• How did you feel when distributing the corn kernels?
• Were you surprised by the result?
• What reasons do you see behind the result? Do you think the result would be different in a different context/at a different time?
• What would a society look like if this value was at the center? What would be different from now?

6. Evaluation in plenary (5-10 minutes)

At the end, everyone comes together in the large group. Plan at least 5 minutes for final thoughts or open questions.

Variants

If there are not enough jars of the same shape and size to hand, the grains can alternatively be placed on a separate empty sheet.

Instead of corn kernels, you can also use something similar, e.g. lentils, rice or even water.

Tips and notes for facilitators

With this method, it is important to create a space in which different perspectives on individual values can coexist. It is not about placing individual values above others. Rather, it is about becoming aware of one’s own values, placing them in a wider context and discussing what this means for society.

Sources:

• Kuhnhenn, K. / Pinnow, A. / Schmelzer, M. / Treu, N. / Konzeptwerk neue Ökonomie e.V. (2020): Zukunft für alle – Eine Vision für 2048: gerecht. ökologisch. Machbar, Oekom.